Atlantic Council

REGISTER

Get Email Updates

Atlantic Update
Printer-friendly version
Subscribe via RSS

UK Commander in Afghanistan Believes Compromise Must be Reached with Taliban

Peter Cassata | October 06, 2008

Brigadier Mark Carleton-Smith, the commander of UK troops in Afghanistan, indicated in an interview with the Times that a political solution with the Taliban was needed for victory in Afghanistan.  He stressed that while the Taliban is very fractured, it is still resilient as an organization even in the face of major losses.  Afghanistan's government has enacted a reconciliation program for Taliban members, but hardcore activists are opposed to any negotiations.

According to the Financial Times, he stated, "We are not going to win this war.  It’s about reducing it to a manageable level of insurgency that’s not a strategic threat and can be managed by the Afghan army."  However, the U.S. remains hesitant about talking to the Taliban.  "It remains to be seen if some in the Taliban will really renounce violence and extremism and play a constructive role in Afghanistan," White House National Security Council spokesman Gordon Johndroe said.

Carleton-Smith's comments follow the recent leak of a French memo that claimed the UK's ambassador to Afghanistan believes winning the war there is impossible.

Atlantic Update Navigation

Blog Roll

Global Leadership Circle